Tuesday, October 18, 2005
Sex, liberty in India, today, yesterday
This is in response to a blog on 25% increase in abortions in the few months after Navratri in India.
Statistics is a very funny thing. So is the tendency of all of us to convert a non-issue to an issue. For a sobering effect let me give one figure: only increase of 1 to 4 is a 25% increase. Hence I don’t think we should jump to the conclusion that a revolutionary or a great moral degrading phenomena is occurring. We may need to find out the figures to come to any conclusion. And as any statistician will tell, practically, the maximum percentage of growth happens only at the initial stages. In that sense we also may conclude that the moral degradation or permissibility or whatever we call it, are still in initial stages and not so alarming.
In the lighter side, I also am not able to figure out where do they do? In the crowded cities how they manage?
This remind me of my old experience of may be of early seventies. On the occasion of Gajan Utsab which falls on the last day of Chaitra month (mid april)I happened to visit one village fare at an Adibasi (tribal) village somewhere in the border of Orissa, Bihar (Now it should be Jharkhand) and West Bengal, in India, the nearest railway station being Dhalbhumgarh on South Eastern Railways.
Since afternoon hundreds of girls and boys were gathering wearing their best of dresses and jewelry (boys with their weaponry of Bows and Arrows, some of them even with their country made guns). At dusk, the girls started dancing forming a ring around a banyan tree accompanied by music of various instruments. The whole place did not have any lighting. Groups of boys were moving around. Some of them carrying even petromax lights. I was a bit surprised as none of them were hanging the lights anywhere to lighten up the area, they were only looking at the girls with the lights. As the night progressed so the crowd. After a couple of hours I noticed that the crowd was getting thinner but could not reason out why or might not have bothered as I was thoroughly enjoying my first encounter with a Adibasi festival and off course I was a kid of may be 17 or 18. By around 10 or 11 p.m. I was fully exhausted with the fatigue of walking some 20 odd kms to reach the place and fell asleep under the tree. Waking up early morning I found that the crowd have vanished. As I was proceeding to my host’s hut on a village road, guess what I encountered with – couples enjoying themselves here and there behind the bushes or any other place they could find.
Later I was told the local custom is something like this: boys and girls meet on this occasion and choose their partners. They stay together for three days during the festival, enjoy themselves and after 3 days, if they continue to like each other, marry and start their married life.
(I always have a longing to go back there again to find out whether the custom prevails till date or not. But I think, I will never go back again to see that the paradise is lost, Rather, I will keep the wish lingering in my mind and cherish the sweet thought.)
I narrated the story for the prudes to remind that the love and physical relationship between Adam and Eve are going on since the advent of humanity and there is nothing immorality in life as long as we don’t dirty it by calling so.
Statistics is a very funny thing. So is the tendency of all of us to convert a non-issue to an issue. For a sobering effect let me give one figure: only increase of 1 to 4 is a 25% increase. Hence I don’t think we should jump to the conclusion that a revolutionary or a great moral degrading phenomena is occurring. We may need to find out the figures to come to any conclusion. And as any statistician will tell, practically, the maximum percentage of growth happens only at the initial stages. In that sense we also may conclude that the moral degradation or permissibility or whatever we call it, are still in initial stages and not so alarming.
In the lighter side, I also am not able to figure out where do they do? In the crowded cities how they manage?
This remind me of my old experience of may be of early seventies. On the occasion of Gajan Utsab which falls on the last day of Chaitra month (mid april)I happened to visit one village fare at an Adibasi (tribal) village somewhere in the border of Orissa, Bihar (Now it should be Jharkhand) and West Bengal, in India, the nearest railway station being Dhalbhumgarh on South Eastern Railways.
Since afternoon hundreds of girls and boys were gathering wearing their best of dresses and jewelry (boys with their weaponry of Bows and Arrows, some of them even with their country made guns). At dusk, the girls started dancing forming a ring around a banyan tree accompanied by music of various instruments. The whole place did not have any lighting. Groups of boys were moving around. Some of them carrying even petromax lights. I was a bit surprised as none of them were hanging the lights anywhere to lighten up the area, they were only looking at the girls with the lights. As the night progressed so the crowd. After a couple of hours I noticed that the crowd was getting thinner but could not reason out why or might not have bothered as I was thoroughly enjoying my first encounter with a Adibasi festival and off course I was a kid of may be 17 or 18. By around 10 or 11 p.m. I was fully exhausted with the fatigue of walking some 20 odd kms to reach the place and fell asleep under the tree. Waking up early morning I found that the crowd have vanished. As I was proceeding to my host’s hut on a village road, guess what I encountered with – couples enjoying themselves here and there behind the bushes or any other place they could find.
Later I was told the local custom is something like this: boys and girls meet on this occasion and choose their partners. They stay together for three days during the festival, enjoy themselves and after 3 days, if they continue to like each other, marry and start their married life.
(I always have a longing to go back there again to find out whether the custom prevails till date or not. But I think, I will never go back again to see that the paradise is lost, Rather, I will keep the wish lingering in my mind and cherish the sweet thought.)
I narrated the story for the prudes to remind that the love and physical relationship between Adam and Eve are going on since the advent of humanity and there is nothing immorality in life as long as we don’t dirty it by calling so.
Comments:
<< Home
Good post. But is it so simple @ prudes ? Girls have to really take care of their reputation, and men and society in general(all around the world ?) has such double standards. Even today.
Frankly speaking I can't answer on behalf of a girl as I am not competent enough to do so.
My thinking process may be too idealistic but I like to go with the feeling of human being without any inhibition as demonstarted by the custom of the tribals I have mentioned. There they don't feel any shame as the society does not put any stigma. I think it all depends on the kind of people you are living with. Regarding men, I believe as far as reputation is concerned men also equally have to take care of their reputation. I do agree that it is difficult for a girl to live as she likes, whereas it is not so with men, they can do whatever they like( but mainly because they are shameless). Regarding double standard of men vs women I have strong reservation about the topic. The base of this strong reservation is built long back with a book of Syed Mustafa ALi or is it Mujaffar Ali. I don't remember exactly and the book is in bengali, I don't think there is any english translation and I am also not sure whether the bengali version also in circulation or not. May be I will post a article soon on the subject.
Thanks for visiting my blog.
Post a Comment
My thinking process may be too idealistic but I like to go with the feeling of human being without any inhibition as demonstarted by the custom of the tribals I have mentioned. There they don't feel any shame as the society does not put any stigma. I think it all depends on the kind of people you are living with. Regarding men, I believe as far as reputation is concerned men also equally have to take care of their reputation. I do agree that it is difficult for a girl to live as she likes, whereas it is not so with men, they can do whatever they like( but mainly because they are shameless). Regarding double standard of men vs women I have strong reservation about the topic. The base of this strong reservation is built long back with a book of Syed Mustafa ALi or is it Mujaffar Ali. I don't remember exactly and the book is in bengali, I don't think there is any english translation and I am also not sure whether the bengali version also in circulation or not. May be I will post a article soon on the subject.
Thanks for visiting my blog.
Subscribe to Post Comments [Atom]
<< Home
Subscribe to Posts [Atom]